Elevated view of two tidy single-story Florida homes with gray shingle roofs, green lawns and palm landscaping.

What The Villages Market Reports Count, and What They Leave Out

In September 2026, the Realtors Association of Lake & Sumter Counties counted 558 active listings in Sumter County. In mid-November, The Villages' in-house brokerage, Properties of The Villages, had about 540 pre-owned homes listed on its own system, the Villages Listing Service. Those 540 homes don't go into the MLS, so they aren't in that 558, and their sales aren't in the median prices that show up in county reports and on national home-search sites.

If you're comparing The Villages with other places, you've probably already seen a median sale price. It describes one of two resale channels, and in this community the two are about the same size.

The number you've already seen

Most published figures for The Villages come from Stellar MLS, the listing system independent agents use across Central Florida. Its county report for October 2026 shows 216 residential sales in Sumter County, a median price of $350,000 and an average of 58 days on market. In the third quarter, Sumter's monthly MLS medians stayed in a narrow band: $343,500 in July, $344,624 in August and $340,000 in September.

The association's September 2026 snapshot points in a different direction. Compared with September 2025, Sumter's new listings rose 26% to 204 while closed sales fell 23% to 121. On paper, more sellers came to market that month and fewer homes closed. It's a reasonable thing to read, as long as you remember the paper only covers MLS listings.

For context, Florida's statewide single-family median was $415,000 in September 2026, with a median of 47 days to contract, according to Florida Realtors' September 2026 report. Next door, Stellar's October 2026 medians were $369,371 in Lake County and $280,000 in Marion County. Side by side, Sumter looks like a moderately priced county with homes that sell at a steady pace. On the MLS side, that's accurate.

The channel the reports don't count

Properties of The Villages is the developer's own brokerage, and its listing system is the VLS. The developer describes the VLS as built around criteria specific to homes and amenities in The Villages and says it is exclusive to Properties of The Villages. VLS listings reach buyers who are already working with the developer's sales offices. MLS listings are shared out to the national portals that most out-of-state buyers search.

This channel is about as big as the MLS side. A public-records feed of the developer's inventory, updated November 16, 2026, counted 840 homes: 300 new and 540 pre-owned. That puts the VLS's 540 pre-owned listings in mid-November at nearly the same number as the 558 active MLS listings the association counted for Sumter in September.

Sales follow the same pattern. In a 2021 federal ruling, covered by Villages-News, Judge James Moody Jr. wrote that "Buyers of homes in The Villages buy multiple times" and that by treating them as lifelong customers, Properties of The Villages "has retained 55 percent of the re-sale market." That figure is five years old. The developer's own current figures say the same thing more strongly. For calendar year 2025, Properties of The Villages reports selling 2,949 pre-owned homes, and it lists Realty Executives, the brokerage Amanda Fincher works under, as next with 483. For comparison, Stellar MLS recorded 1,676 Sumter County sales across the first three quarters of 2026, and that county total includes sales outside The Villages.

In the developer's listing feed, each home shows an asking price and how long it has been listed. What the VLS side lacks is the monthly roundup the MLS side gets in county reports, with a median sale price, average days on market and closed-sale counts. In practice, the most active resale channel in The Villages has the fewest published monthly statistics.

What that does to a median

A monthly median depends on which homes happened to close that month. When the mix of homes changes, the median can move even if no single home gained or lost value. So the useful question for any Villages median is which homes it includes.

Look at Sumter's October 2026 MLS figures. The median was $350,000 and the average was $434,225. A gap of about $84,000 means some higher-priced sales pulled the average well above the middle. Which homes those were, and whether similar homes were closing on the VLS that month, can't be seen from the MLS report.

The developer's inventory has its own mix. Of the 840 homes in the November 16 feed, 379 are in the Eastport area. By village, the largest groups are Merritt Field with 181, Middleton with 54 and Long Prairie with 51. The combined median asking price, new and pre-owned together, was $399,711. That's an asking price, and it includes new construction, so it isn't comparable to the MLS median sale price. It does show that the developer's channel holds a large share of the newest villages south of the older squares. If a buyer looks only at the MLS, those villages are underrepresented.

Price movement looks similar in the feed. Across the 840 developer-listed homes, 293 showed an observed price reduction and 175 had been listed for 90 days or more as of November 16. In Long Prairie, four new Patio Villas were reduced by $8,401, $8,968, $9,036 and $10,449 after 112 to 140 days on the market. MLS days-on-market figures don't include any of these homes.

The reverse matters too. The September jump in MLS new listings and drop in MLS closings could mean the market is softening. It could also mean the share of sellers choosing each channel shifted. The MLS report alone can't tell those two apart.

Pricing a specific home

The broad numbers still have a use. The median helps you set a budget, and the county comparisons tell you where The Villages sits among nearby markets. Once you're looking at a particular address, local comparison works better than county-wide figures.

A good comparison for a Patio Villa near Brownwood is other Patio Villas near Brownwood that sold recently, from either channel. Sumter's countywide median doesn't help much there. The different parts of The Villages price differently because of age, home style, golf access and the bond and assessment picture. That last factor is one we've covered before: the CDD maintenance assessment can matter more than the bond. A comparison that leaves out half the sales from a home's own area is likely to have the price wrong. It could be too high or too low.

Timing has the same gap. A 58-day MLS average in October 2026 shows how fast MLS-listed homes sold that month. The new Long Prairie villas reduced after four months on the market are a separate data point, from a separate channel, and you need both to see how fast homes in a given village are actually selling.

For buyers relocating from out of state, the issue is mostly practical. National portals pull from the MLS, so a search done from home may show about half of what's for sale. Our guide to buying in The Villages from out of state covers how to plan a search from a distance. Before you decide a part of The Villages has few homes for sale, or that its prices are firm, check both channels.

Quick answers

Is the Sumter County median the median for The Villages? It is the median for MLS sales in all of Sumter County. That includes some sales outside The Villages and leaves out sales handled through the developer's VLS.

Does the developer's channel only handle new homes? No. In the November 16, 2026 feed, 540 of the 840 developer-listed homes were pre-owned.

Which number is better for planning a budget? Use the MLS median for a broad budget and recent sales of similar homes nearby, from both channels, for a specific address.

If you already own a home here and want a value based on how homes in your village actually sold, from both channels, Amanda Fincher, LLC will put together a free home valuation using comparable sales from your own part of The Villages. If you're still deciding where in The Villages to buy, our buyer page is a good place to start, and Amanda can walk you through the numbers that apply to the homes you're considering.

Ready to Make a Move?

Whether you're buying or selling in The Villages or the surrounding areas, I've got you covered.

Follow Me on Instagram